Table 7 Co-production information from the selected studies in this review
Article # | First author | Conceptualisation | Design and planning | Empirical | Analytic and dissemination | Full co-production elements | Total level |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Angell [18] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full | |
2 | Armstrong [19] | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | |
3 | Bohanna [20] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods | Indigenous developed research tools | Authorship, feedback or editing | Full | |
4 | Cheok [21] | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | ||
5 | Clapham [22] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full |
6 | Cochrane [23] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant Indigenous developed research tools | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full | |
7 | Coombes [24] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full | |
8 | Cotter [25] | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | |||
9 | Dossetor [26] | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | ||
10 | Edmonston [27] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods | Some | |||
11 | Esgin [28] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Indigenous developed research tools | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Community led or participatory research Identified team members | Full | |
12 | Falster [29] | Advisory group/consultation | Minimal | ||||
13 | Fraser [30] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | |
14 | Gauld [31] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Community led or participatory research | Full | |
15 | Hill [32] | Identified research clinician /research assistant Indigenous developed research tools | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full | ||
16 | Katzenellenbogen [33] | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | ||
17 | Keel [34] | Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | |||
18 | Lee [35] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing | Some | ||
19 | LoGiudice [36] | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Affiliation | Some | ||
20 | Lukaszyk [37] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full | |
21 | Lukaszyk [38] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant Indigenous developed research tools | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full |
22 | Lukaszyk [39] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full |
23 | Lukaszyk [40] | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Some | |||
24 | Lukaszyk [41] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full |
25 | McAuley [42] | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | ||
26 | Moller [43] | Advisory group/consultation | Authorship, feedback or editing | Some | |||
27 | Moller [44] | Advisory group/consultation | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full | ||
28 | Moller [45] | Advisory group/consultation | Authorship, feedback or editing | Some | |||
29 | Moller [46] | Advisory group/consultation | Authorship, feedback or editing | Some | |||
30 | Phillips [47] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Some | |||
31 | Ryder [48] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | ||
32 | Ryder [49] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | |
33 | Schultz [50] | Indigenous/decolonising methods Indigenous specific ethics committee | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing | Community led or participatory research Identified team members | Full | |
34 | Shepherd [51] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Some | |||
35 | Smith [3] | Indigenous/decolonising methods | Minimal | ||||
36 | Thurber [52] | Indigenous specific ethics committee | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full | ||
37 | Veli-Gold [53] | Indigenous/decolonising methods | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing | Identified team members | Full | |
38 | Wallis [54] | Authorship, feedback or editing | Minimal | ||||
39 | Williams [55] | Advisory group/consultation | Indigenous/decolonising methods | Identified research clinician /research assistant | Authorship, feedback or editing Affiliation | Identified team members | Full |